Tuesday, May 15, 2012

Readicide


Genre fiction is not less "worthy" that literary fiction but, rather, have different purposes. Both types of books are important in their own sense and that should be taken into account in judging them. Literary fiction is appreciated because of its artistic and literary elements. They are books that require the reader to think critically about certain issues or ideas. Genre fictions are the books that the public reads for enjoyment and as a result they have the highest sales. These plot-driven, character focused, engaging books may lack the strong writing of their literary counterparts. I find both types of books are important and should be treated similarly, keeping in mind the purposes of each. Though I believe they both follow some of the same guidlines genre fiction books can, and do have spectacular writing and literary fiction can have a very captivating plotline. "I read a lot of commercial fiction and a lot of the same themes and wisdoms I find in commercial fiction are the same themes and wisdoms as what I see lauded in literary fiction". Jodi Picoult said this and I completely agree because even though people would like to think genre fiction and literary fiction are so different, the core of them are the same.
Schools should add commercial books into the reading curriculum. A good mix of both literary and genre fiction would give students the ability to read books they like but also appreciate the artistic qualities of literary fiction. The way the schools teach books in today's classrooms turn off students to reading of both the classics and popular fiction. Very seldom can students just read a book without worrying to have to do many little activities along the way, analyzing every single chapter. The best solution is to have a mix of both types of books with less analysis of the books because honestly nobody likes to have that many distractions when they are reading a book they like.

9 comments:

  1. I agree that schools should add in more commercial books because kids would enjoy reading more. There also should be a good balance between literary and genre fiction.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Adding books students liek to read will improve their enjoyment of reading. A lot of students don't like reading because we have to read books that don't iinterest us, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't read them. I agree that there should be a good balance.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that literary fiction and genre fiction are simialr as well, and they both can have great writing and a great plot line.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree that both types of books are important, and that there should be a mix of literary and genre fiction books.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with you on how literary ficiton has its own way of being appreciated and so does genre fiction.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree all books have there own purpose and one is not better than the other.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The classics have no purpose in today’s world, we have newer better books to read now that do a much better job and are more fun to read.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with a lot of your second paragraph, about having a solid mix of literary classics and todays popular novels. Having to analyze small details and read at a certain pace deffinitly turns readers away and detracts from the enjoyment of a good story.

    ReplyDelete
  9. "The way the schools teach books in today's classrooms turn off students to reading of both the classics and popular fiction." You and I had the same conversation about this topic; it is not the books that are making problems for children and their education, it is the way that the teachers teach the students to over-analyze books and hate the sticky disposition of scrawled on post-its. It is nice to see a perspective so similiar to my own. :)

    ReplyDelete